When it comes to securing your home or property, the state of your locks is crucial. But here’s the big question: should you rekey your locks or replace them entirely? Each option has its advantages, and the right choice often depends on your specific situation.
In this guide, we’ll break down the costs, benefits, and practical considerations of rekeying and replacing locks. By the end, you’ll have the insights you need to make an informed decision that fits your budget and security needs.
Rekeying: What It Is and When to Choose It
Rekeying is a process where a professional locksmith adjusts the internal mechanisms of a lock so it works with a new key. It’s an excellent solution for various situations, such as:
- Moving into a new property: Ensure previous occupants no longer have access.
- Lost or stolen keys: Regain control of your security quickly.
- Master key systems: Simplify access for properties with multiple locks.
Advantages of Rekeying
Rekeying locks is often a cost-effective solution, as it doesn’t require purchasing new hardware. The process is quick, allowing you to secure your property with minimal disruption. Plus, it lets you retain your current locks, which is great if they’re in good condition and match your décor.
Limitations of Rekeying
While rekeying is affordable, it doesn’t provide significant security upgrades. Rekeying won’t solve these issues if your existing locks are outdated or damaged. For enhanced security, you may want to consider other options, such as upgrading to high-security locks.
Also Read: How Often Should You Replace Your Locks? Key Signs to Know
Replacing Locks: What It Entails and When to Do It
Replacing locks involves removing the current lock system and installing a new one. This option is ideal in scenarios like:
- Damaged or worn-out locks: Old or broken locks need replacing for reliable security.
- Upgrading to high-security locks: Protect your home with advanced technology like anti-pick or smart locks.
- Changing aesthetics: Refresh the look of your doors while improving functionality.
Advantages of Replacing Locks
Replacing locks allows you to enhance your home security significantly. You can opt for modern smart lock technology or locks designed to resist picking and bumping. Additionally, replacing locks lets you update the appearance of your doors, combining style with practicality.
Drawbacks of Replacing Locks
The main downside to replacing locks is the cost. Purchasing new locks and paying for professional lock installation can be expensive. The process also takes more time compared to rekeying. However, replacing locks is often worth the investment for long-term security upgrades.
Also Read: Common Lock Issues & Signs You Need a Locksmith Now
Cost Comparison: Rekeying vs. Replacing Locks
Breakdown of Costs
Rekeying is generally the more affordable option. Locksmith services for rekeying typically range from $20 to $50 per lock, plus a service fee. On the other hand, replacing locks involves the cost of new hardware, which can range from $50 to $300 or more per lock, depending on the type. Professional installation adds to this expense.
Factors That Impact Costs
The type of lock you choose—standard, high-security, or smart—plays a significant role in determining costs. Additional fees may apply for emergency locksmith services or after-hours assistance. It’s essential to consider these factors when budgeting for your home security upgrades.
Long-Term Costs
While rekeying locks is cheaper upfront, replacing locks can offer long-term savings by reducing the need for frequent maintenance or future upgrades. Investing in durable, high-quality locks can pay off in the long run.
Security Considerations for Rekeying vs. Replacing
Rekeying Security Features
Rekeying locks is an effective way to quickly restrict access, especially if you’ve lost your keys or are moving into a new home. However, it retains the existing lock hardware, which may not meet today’s security standards.
Replacing Security Features
Replacing locks gives you the opportunity to enhance protection with modern features like anti-pick and anti-bump technology. For the ultimate in convenience and security, consider upgrading to smart locks, which offer remote access and monitoring.
Best Practices for Security
To maintain optimal security, regularly assess the condition of your locks. Combining rekeying and replacing locks can be a strategic approach. For example, rekey locks to restrict access immediately and plan for a lock replacement as a long-term solution.
Also Read: How to Select the Right Locksmith Service for Your Needs
Pros and Cons Recap
Rekeying
Pros: Affordable, quick, retains existing hardware.
Cons: Limited security upgrades, relies on the quality of current locks.
Replacing Locks
Pros: Improved security, customizable options, supports advanced technology.
Cons: Higher upfront cost, longer installation time.
Find the Right Solution with ASAP Locksmith
Deciding between rekeying and replacing locks ultimately depends on your needs, budget, and the condition of your current locks. Rekeying is an excellent choice for quick, affordable security updates while replacing locks offers enhanced protection and modern features.
If you’re unsure about the best option for your property, consult a professional locksmith for expert advice. We specialize in lock replacement, residential locksmith, and commercial locksmith services at ASAP Locksmith. Whether you need help with a car lockout or a complete home security upgrade, we’ve got you covered.
Ready to take the next step? Contact ASAP Locksmith today for reliable, affordable lock solutions. Let us help you secure your property with confidence.

You Might Also Like
How Much Do Locksmith Services Cost? A Comprehensive Guide
Have you ever found yourself locked out of your home, car, or office and wondered, “How much will a locksmith [...]
How Often Should You Replace Your Locks? Key Signs to Watch For
Locks are your first line of defence when it comes to protecting your home or business. Yet, many people overlook [...]
Are Smart Locks Secure? Pros, Cons, and What to Consider
Smart locks have become a popular choice for Canadian homeowners seeking greater convenience and better control over their home security. [...]